When Hayley accepts an invitation to spend Christmas with her sister’s new in-laws, her seemingly perfect holiday takes a turn when Paul, Hayley's brother-in-law's brother, unexpectedly shows up. Still harboring a grudge against Paul for ending her last relationship, Hayley reluctantly spends time with Paul and slowly realizes she may have been too quick a judge on Paul
Chad Michael Murray
as Paul Barnett
Jessica Lowndes
as Hayley Parker
Steve Byers
as Tim Barnett
Rob Stewart
as Penn Barnett
Deanna Jarvis
as Michelle Larson
Chris Farquhar
as Trey
Phil Popp
as Joe
Fiona Highet
as Patti Larson
Ellora Patnaik
as Kim
Josh Bainbridge
as Taxi Driver
Seana McKenna
as Judy Barnett
Vanessa Sears
as Amy Parker-Barnett
