Miles apart, Molly and Lily become pen pals at 4th grade, continuing to write to each other throughout their lives. Things change however when Molly shows up at Lily's 25th Birthday, with an intention of taking over Lily's life.
Natalie Dreyfuss
as Molly
Elise Gatien
as Lily Anderson
Tom Stevens
as Matthew
Michael Denis
as Gordon Emory
Cassandra Ebner
as Real Molly
Sam Spear
as Detective Wolf
Abbie Magnuson
as Young Lily
Tracy Waterhouse
as Lily's Mom
