Billy, once the coolest kid in high school, comes back to his hometown 15 years later to find he’s no longer cool and the girl he still has feelings for now dates the former class outcast. Billy becomes obsessed with proving the outcast is a murderer.
Adam Pally
as Billy
Rachel Bloom
as Kara
Vincent Kartheiser
as Lowell
John Reynolds
as Perkins
Didi Conn
as Billy's Mom
Ethan Phillips
as Billy's Dad
Doug Mand
as Duane
Hasan Minhaj
as Amir
Rebecca Naomi Jones
as Elana
Julia Goldani Telles
as Tammy
Don Fanelli
as Officer Matarazzo
Billy Eichner
as Speigel
