Alex, a lovable, unassuming dog trainer is in love with a great woman - Katherine - smart, talented, from a good family. Katherine adores Alex's quirky sense of humor, honesty and capacity to listen. Having decided to pop the question, Alex is blindsided when Katherine produces a detailed list of well-thought-out "improvements" she feels will tweak Alex on their way to becoming the ideal couple. Alex instinctively rejects the suggestion that he needs to change anything. But with the threat of a new competitor, Alex decides to "do the list." Guided by a coterie of friends that include: Dave, Alex's loyal childhood buddy, best female friend Lily, her husband Michael, and their 8 year old son, Nicky, Alex's journey has him reconsider and question his beliefs, values and world.
Patrick Fugit
as Alex Buckingham
Jennifer Morrison
as Katherine Stern
Karen Gillan
as Lily
Aaron Staton
as Michael
Eddie Kaye Thomas
as Dave
Michael Nouri
as Rabbi Baskin
Gilles Marini
as Dr. Antonio Rosenblatt
Ryan O'Nan
as Gary
Elvy
as Anastasiya
Lesley-Anne Down
as Victoria
JoBeth Williams
as Mrs. Stern
Bob Gunton
as Mr. Stern
