Adam and Steve are two gay youths who have a one-night stand that ends embarrassingly. Nearly two decades later, Adam, now a Manhattan tour guide, and Steve, a psychiatrist, meet again -- but neither remembers the other from years before. The two begin dating, even playing matchmaker for their friends Michael and Rhonda, but their promising relationship hits a major snag when Adam and Steve finally recall their past connection.
Craig Chester
as Adam Bernstein
Malcolm Gets
as Steve Hicks
Parker Posey
as Rhonda
Chris Kattan
as Michael
Kristen Schaal
as Ruth
Julie Hagerty
as Sherry
Paul Sand
as Norm
Noah Segan
as Twink
Sally Kirkland
as Mary
Melinda Dillon
as Dottie
Thomas Kopache
as Joe
Todd Robert Anderson
as Charlie
